Carnelian
Orange-red to red-brown translucent chalcedony; color from iron oxide (hematite/goethite). Carnelian is lighter and more orange than sard (darker brown-red). Heat treatment of brown agate to produce carnelian is a traditional and accepted practice. Dyeing is also common; color concentrated in surface fissures under loupe is a detection indicator. Modern commercial carnelian is often dyed agate.
Physical & Optical Properties
Related: Quartz Varieties
Key Differentiators
- Translucent orange-red to red-brown body color — primary identifier
- Waxy luster; even color distribution (uniform, not banded)
- Holds light from within when backlit — thin edges show translucency
- Distinguish from sard by lighter, more orange color (sard is darker brown)
- Distinguish from red jasper by translucency (jasper is fully opaque)
- Heat treatment from brown agate to bright carnelian is traditional and expected
Common Simulants
- Red/orange glass: Isotropic; gas bubbles; lower SG; no waxy luster.
- Red jasper: Fully opaque; same species but jasper contains up to 20% other minerals; lacks translucency of carnelian.
Treatments
- Heat Treatment (traditional — agate heated to produce/brighten orange-red; widely accepted)
- Dyed (common — color in fissures under 10×; acetone test)
Price Context
Price context is approximate. GemID is not an appraisal tool. Results are indicators, not certified valuations.
About Carnelian
Orange-red to red-brown translucent chalcedony; color from iron oxide (hematite/goethite). Carnelian is lighter and more orange than sard (darker brown-red). Heat treatment of brown agate to produce carnelian is a traditional and accepted practice. Dyeing is also common; color concentrated in surface fissures under loupe is a detection indicator. Modern commercial carnelian is often dyed agate.
Identifying a carnelian? GemID walks through these tests in order — RI, SG, fluorescence, and more.
Try GemID Free →